The Replication Network
Furthering the Practice of Replication in Economics
Archives
What Can Meta-Analyses Tell Us About Reproducibility?
Posted on by replicationnetwork
[From the abstract of the article “What Meta-Analyses Reveal About the Replicability of Psychological Research” by T.D. Stanley, Evan Carter, and Hristos Doucouliagos, published in Psychological Bulletin] “Can recent failures to replicate psychological research be explained by typical magnitudes of statistical power,bias…
Read MoreCategory: NEWS & EVENTS Tags: Chris Doucouliagos, Heterogeneity, Meta-analysis, Power, Psychological Bulletin, Psychology, replication, Tom Stanley
Are Meta-Analyses Overrated?
Posted on by replicationnetwork
[From the article, “Meta-analyses were supposed to end scientific debates. Often, they only cause more controversy” by Jop de Vrieze, published at http://www.sciencemag.org%5D “Meta-analyses were thought to be debate enders, but now we know they rarely are,” Ferguson says. “They should…
Read MoreCategory: NEWS & EVENTS Tags: Cochrane, Media violence, Meta-analysis, Science journal, Video games
IN THE NEWS: Wired (November 14, 2017)
Posted on by replicationnetwork
[From the article “The Dismal Science Remains Dismal, Say Scientists” by Adam Rogers at wired.com] “WHEN HRISTOS DOUCOULIAGOS was a young economist in the mid-1990s, he got interested in all the ways economics was wrong about itself—bias, underpowered research, statistical shenanigans. Nobody wanted…
Read MoreCategory: NEWS & EVENTS Tags: COLIN CAMERER, Hristos Doucouliagos, John Ioannidis, Meta-analysis, Reproducibility, Underpowered
FYI: ScienceOpen Has a Collection of Papers on How to Fix the Replicability Crisis
Posted on by replicationnetwork
ScienceOpen has a collection entitled: “Remedies to the Reproducibility Crisis”. The collection is introduced thusly: “Psychology, Medicine, Neuroscience and many other research fields, are facing a serious reproducibility crisis, that is, most of the findings published in peer-review journals, independently…
Read MoreConcurrent Replication
Posted on by replicationnetwork
[From Rolf Zwaan’s blog “Zeitgeist”.] “A form of replication that has received not much attention yet is what I will call concurrent replication. The basic idea is this. A research group formulates a hypothesis that they want to test. At…
Read MoreCategory: NEWS & EVENTS Tags: Concurrent replication, Meta-analysis, Pre-registration, replication, Rolf Zwaan
Another Session on Reproducibility at the 2017 ASSA Meetings
Posted on by replicationnetwork
TRN previously posted about two sessions on replication at the 2017 ASSA meetings. In what may be a sign of changing times, the American Economic Association is sponsoring a third session on this topic. The session, “Meta-Analysis and Reproducibility in…
Read MoreCategory: Uncategorised Tags: BITSS, Chris Doucouliagos, John Ioannidis, Meta-analysis, Reproducibility, SSMART grants, Tom Stanley
Everything is F**KED: The Syllabus
Posted on by replicationnetwork
Come on, admit it. This is the course you really want to teach. Professor Sanjay Srivastava’s PSY607’s weekly topics include: –Significance testing is f**ked — Causal inference from experiments is f**ked — Replicability is f**ked — Scientific publishing is f**ked…
Read MoreCategory: NEWS & EVENTS Tags: f**ked, Meta-analysis, replication, Sanjay Srivastava, significance testing, Syllabus
ETIENNE LEBEL: Introducing “CurateScience.Org”
Posted on by replicationnetwork
It is my pleasure to introduce Curate Science (http://CurateScience.org) to The Replication Network. Curate Science is a web application that aims to facilitate and incentivize the curation and verification of empirical results in the social sciences (initial focus in Psychology)….
Read MoreCategory: GUEST BLOGS Tags: CurateScience.org, Etienne LeBel, Forest plot, Meta-analysis, Psychology
ARJEN VAN WITTELOOSTUIJN: A Manifesto, and a Petition
Posted on by replicationnetwork
Science is a community of human beings of the homo sapiens species: bipedals with the capacity to be self-reflexive. This implies that science as a community is subject to all the same behavioral patterns that all human communities are, including…
Read MoreCategory: GUEST BLOGS Tags: Manifesto, Meta-analysis, Petition, Popper, replication, Van Witteloostuijn
You Say Replication. I say Meta-analysis.
Posted on by replicationnetwork
In this article from Time Higher Education, WOLFGANG STROEBE and MILES HEWSTONE ask “What have we learned from the Reproducibility Project?” The short answer is — in their opinion — not much. Instead, they argue that the replicating researchers would have…
Read MoreCategory: NEWS & EVENTS Tags: Meta-analysis, Miles Hewstone, Psychology, Reproducibility Project, Wolfgang Stroebe
Tags
Andrew Gelman BITSS Brian Nosek Center for Open Science Data sharing economics Journal policies Nature journal null hypothesis significance testing Open Science p-hacking p-values Pre-registration Psychology publication bias replication replication crisis replications Reproducibility TransparencyBlogroll
Recent Posts
- HIRSCHAUER, GRÜNER, & MUßHOFF: Fundamentals of Statistical Inference: What is the Meaning of Random Error?
- ATTENTION REPLICATORS: CALL FOR PAPER PROPOSALS (an I4R collaborative initiative)
- Be a Part of the Next Big Thing! Join the Multi100 Project
- REED & WU: EiR* – Missing Data
- BRODEUR: Launching the Institute for Replication (I4R)
The Replication Network 
You must be logged in to post a comment.